Administrative Review Board Decisions
The following case summaries were created by the Administrative Review Board staff.
Waid v. Alaska Airlines, Inc., ARB No. 2025-0082, ALJ No. 2025-AIR-00010 (ARB Oct. 26, 2026) (Decision and Order)
TIMELINESS; OSHA COMPLAINT; FINAL, DEFINITIVE, UNEQUIVOCAL NOTICE OF ADVERSE EMPLOYMENT DECISION
In Waid v. Alaska Airlines, Inc., ARB No. 2025-0082, ALJ No. 2025-AIR-00010 (ARB Oct. 26, 2026), the ARB reversed the ALJ's dismissal of Complainant's AIR21 whistleblower complaint alleging that Respondent terminated him in retaliation for protected activity. The ALJ found the complaint untimely, treating Respondent's July 29, 2024 letter stating its intent to terminate Complainant for failure to progress in training as the date the 90-day limitations period began. The ARB held that the ALJ erred as a matter of law by concluding that Respondent's July 29, 2024 letter communicated its final decision to terminate Complainant.
The ALJ found it undisputed that Respondent notified Complainant of its intent to terminate him on July 29, 2024, formally terminated him on August 19, 2024, and that Complainant filed his OSHA complaint on November 15, 2024. The ALJ also noted that it was undisputed that the July 29, 2024 letter allowed Complainant to request an initial hearing under Section 19 of the collective bargaining agreement, and that he participated in that hearing on August 15, 2024.
Reading the two letters together and in the light most favorable to Complainant, the ARB found that the August 19, 2024 letter was the operative final termination notice. That letter stated that, after reviewing all relevant information, including information Complainant provided at the August 15, 2024 hearing, Respondent "hereby terminated" his employment. The ARB found that this language showed Respondent's review preceded the final decision and that the language "hereby" supported the conclusion that termination was accomplished by the August 19, 2024 letter. The ARB also noted that the August 19, 2024 letter did not state that Respondent was reaffirming or confirming a final decision it had already communicated on July 29, 2024.
The ARB explained that, under AIR21 and similar whistleblower statutes, the limitations period begins when a complainant receives "final, definitive, and unequivocal notice of an adverse employment decision." "'Final' and 'definitive' notice denotes communication that is decisive or conclusive, i.e., leaving no further chance for action, discussion, or change. 'Unequivocal' notice means communication that is not ambiguous, i.e., free of misleading possibilities." Applying that standard, the ARB held that the July 29, 2024 letter was not final, definitive, and unequivocal because it expressed an intent to terminate while also giving Complainant an opportunity to request an initial hearing.
The ARB further concluded that the initial hearing could reasonably be viewed as part of Respondent's decision-making process because it gave Complainant the opportunity to influence the termination decision before it became final. The Board concluded that the July 29, 2024 and August 19, 2024 letters supported the conclusion that the August 15, 2024 initial hearing in which Complainant participated was part of Respondent's decision-making process and that his termination was not finally, definitively, and unequivocally decided and communicated until the August 19, 2024 letter. Thus, the ARB held, Complainant's November 15, 2024 OSHA complaint was filed within AIR21's 90-day limitations period.
TIMELINESS; NOVEMBER 15, 2024 COMPLAINT ALLEGED ACTIVITY POTENTIALLY PROTECTED UNDER AIR21
The ARB also rejected Respondent's argument that the AIR21 complaint was not filed until November 27, 2024, and found it filed on November 15, 2024, when OSHA received Complainant's allegations that he raised concerns about an early-morning flight assignment, his medical condition, and the effects of abrupt changes in sleep and caffeine consumption. Although partly framed as a medical accommodation request, the ARB concluded the allegations could reasonably be read as a fitness-to-fly concern potentially protected under AIR21. Because no particular form of complaint is required and whistleblower complaints may be supplemented during OSHA's review, the ARB deemed the November 15, 2024 filing timely, reversed the dismissal, and remanded.
Branch v. Illinois Central Railroad Co., ARB No. 2026-0063, ALJ No. 2023-FRS-00026 (ARB Oct. 15, 2026) (Order of Dismissal)
DISMISSAL OF COMPLAINT; NOTICE OF FILING IN FEDERAL DISTRICT COURT; REMOVAL; KICKOUT
In Branch v. Illinois Central Railroad Co., ARB No. 2026-0063, ALJ No. 2023-FRS-00026 (ARB Oct. 15, 2026), the ARB dismissed Complainant's appeal because he filed an original action seeking de novo review in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi pursuant to 49 U.S.C. § 20109(d)(3) and 29 C.F.R. § 1982.114(a), and thus the Department of Labor no longer had jurisdiction over the matter.
Carpenter v. FedEx Freight, ARB No. 2025-0036, ALJ No. 2023-STA-00033 (ARB Oct. 5, 2026) (Decision and Order)
SAME-ACTION DEFENSE; SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTED ALJ'S CONCLUSION THAT RESPONDENT WOULD HAVE TERMINATED COMPLAINANT FOR ALTERING A BILL OF LADING EVEN ABSENT PROTECTED ACTIVITY
In Carpenter v. FedEx Freight, ARB No. 2025-0036, ALJ No. 2023-STA-00033 (ARB Oct. 5, 2026), the ARB affirmed the ALJ's conclusion that Respondent would have terminated Complainant even in the absence of her protected activity.
Complainant worked for Respondent as a Service Center Support employee whose duties included customer billing. On November 2, 2022, Respondent's Operations Manager asked Complainant about a shipment from a regular customer that was unconfirmed and missing a bill of lading (BOL). Respondent's policies required each shipment to have its own BOL, treated BOLs as important shipping and contractual documents, and provided procedures for missing or corrected BOLs. Rather than hold the shipment until the original BOL could be located or obtain proper corrected documentation under company practice and policy, Complainant copied an old BOL from a prior shipment from the customer, whited out and changed the addressee information, changed the weight and tracking number, and left the shipper's signature in place. Respondent soon discovered the altered BOL, investigated the incident, and terminated Complainant's employment for falsification of company records.
Complainant alleged that Respondent actually terminated her in retaliation for repeatedly raising concerns that foodstuffs were being shipped alongside poison or were not being properly identified to ensure safe transport. The ALJ found that Complainant engaged in protected activity under the Surface Transportation Assistance Act and the Food Safety Modernization Act, but dismissed the complaint after concluding that Complainant failed to prove her protected activity contributed to the termination of her employment and that Respondent proved by clear and convincing evidence that it would have terminated her employment even absent the protected activity.
The ARB concluded that substantial evidence supported the ALJ's conclusion that Respondent would have terminated Complainant because she altered or manufactured the BOL. The ARB found several factors supported Respondent's defense. Respondent promptly investigated after discovering the altered BOL and terminated Complainant shortly thereafter. Its policies identified falsification of company documents and providing false or misleading information as serious offenses warranting possible immediate removal and termination. Respondent consistently explained that the BOL alteration was the sole reason for termination, and the contemporaneous investigation materials focused on that incident rather than on Complainant's prior protected complaints. The ARB also noted that Complainant had raised shipping-related concerns for years without being terminated; Respondent acted only after the BOL incident.
The ARB also relied on comparator evidence showing that other employees at the same facility who violated Respondent's dishonesty or falsification policies were terminated, although they had not engaged in protected activity and had not committed precisely the same misconduct as Complainant. The ARB reiterated that comparator evidence need not involve precisely identical misconduct. A comparator may be relevant if the employee committed the same or similar violation, with the degree of similarity affecting the weight of the evidence. Although the comparators did not alter BOLs, they violated the same falsification or dishonesty rules and were terminated. Complainant did not identify employees who altered or manufactured BOLs but were treated more favorably.
The ARB also rejected Complainant's arguments that her actions were harmless, permissible, or approved by a manager. Her assertion that she was trained to update BOLs in this manner was unsupported and inconsistent with her claim that the incident resulted from a lack of training. Her claim that a manager approved the alteration was also unsupported and contradicted by the investigation record, which showed that the manager expected her to locate the BOL or follow missing-BOL procedures.
Finally, the ARB emphasized that it does not sit as a super-personnel department to second-guess an employer's business judgment. The question was not whether termination was harsh or whether the ARB would have imposed the same discipline, but whether Respondent proved it would have terminated Complainant absent her protected activity. Because substantial evidence supported the ALJ's finding that Respondent met that burden by clear and convincing evidence, the ARB affirmed dismissal of the complaint.