Enforcement Alert – Best Practices for Protecting Participants and Beneficiaries from Inaccurate Network Provider Directories

This page is most useful for: Employer

The Department of Labor (Department) is committed to helping American workers and their families access care through in-network health providers. However, the Department has found errors in plan network provider directories that make it harder for participants and their beneficiaries to access covered care. Employers and plan fiduciaries can help improve directory accuracy by following the best practices in this alert.

Background

Maintaining accurate provider directories is a shared responsibility under Federal law. While healthcare providers are responsible for submitting timely and accurate provider directory information to the health plans and health insurance issuers with which they participate,(1) health plans and health insurance issuers are responsible for regularly verifying, updating, and publishing accurate provider directory information.

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) section 720, group health plans and health insurance issuers must:

  • Implement a process to verify and update their online provider directories at least once every ninety days;
  • Update online provider directories within two business days of learning of an inaccuracy or change in a provider’s information;
  • Develop protocols to respond to requests from participants and beneficiaries to verify a provider’s network status within 1 business day of request made by telephone; and
  • Impose in-network cost sharing where a plan or issuer provides incorrect provider directory information that a provider was an in-network provider and the participant and beneficiary goes to that provider

Fiduciaries also may be in violation of ERISA section 404 if they fail to take steps to maintain accurate provider directories.

Inaccurate Directories Harm Participants and Beneficiaries

Accurate provider directories help participants and beneficiaries find providers that participate in the plan’s network and agree to accept the plan’s rates as payment in full. Unfortunately, inaccurate provider directories remain a common and frustrating problem. In recent surveys, the Department contacted more than 27,000 providers across 27 networks and found that incorrect directory information was listed for 36% of the providers on average.

Bottom line: Inaccurate provider directories can harm participants and beneficiaries in several ways, including:

  • Delays in care
  • Forgoing treatment due to the inability to find in-network providers
  • Higher out-of-pocket costs from using out-of-network providers
  • Unexpected medical bills
  • Choosing a plan during open enrollment that does not include desired providers

Stay Alert: Employers and fiduciaries should not assume directory information is accurate. For example, complaints from participants and beneficiaries about difficulty finding in-network providers may be an early warning sign. Complaints may point to inaccurate provider directory information.

Protect participants and beneficiaries from inaccurate provider directories. This alert will help you:

1. Follow best practices

to evaluate provider directory accuracy.

2. Ask the right questions

when working with your service provider to monitor and update directory information.

3. Learn from EBSA's Secret Shopper Surveys

about how common these problems are and how they affect access to care.

Best Practices

Plans are required to implement certain practices for their provider directories. These practices help protect participants and beneficiaries from the harm of inaccurate provider directory information, while supporting compliance with the law.

Establish a process to review and update directories regularly

Ensure you or your service provider follows the law by verifying and updating online provider directory information at least once every 90 days. Establish a procedure to remove providers from the provider directory if you are unable to verify their provider directory information during a specified period. When you learn from a provider that there has been a change in a provider’s information, ensure the online directory is updated within two business days.

Enable quick in-network verification

Ensure participants and beneficiaries can verify a provider’s network status within one business day of a request made by telephone.

Ensure in-network cost sharing protections are followed

If information about network participation is incorrect, participants and beneficiaries should not be charged more than in-network cost sharing rates. All such cost sharing applies toward any in-network deductible or in-network out-of-pocket maximum.

Monitor complaints and document them

Maintain records of issues related to directory accuracy and actions taken to address them. Prudently monitor your service provider’s response to issues and the impact on access to care for participants and beneficiaries.

Questions to Ask

Below are some questions you can ask your service provider to better understand how they maintain and update provider directories:

  • Do you have a written policy for verifying and updating directory information? Can you share a copy of it?
  • How do you verify and update directory information? If you do conduct regular audits or accuracy checks, in addition to complying with ERISA section 720 requirements, what benchmarks do you use, and are you meeting them?
  • Have you considered implementing a process, including reviewing claims data, for identifying providers who are no longer in-network?
  • Do you conduct outreach or surveys to verify directory information? Do you use third-party services to conduct the outreach or surveys?
  • What is your process for removing a provider from the directory? How quickly do you make updates once you learn of a change?
  • How do you track and document participants’ and beneficiaries’ complaints about network access, directory accuracy, or difficulty finding an in-network provider? How do you address these complaints?
  • What protections are in place for participants and beneficiaries who rely on incorrect directory information related to network participation? For example, how do you ensure that cost-sharing is limited to in-network amounts?

Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) Secret Shopper Surveys

EBSA conducted secret shopper surveys to assess provider directory accuracy and whether participants and beneficiaries could rely on those directories to access care.

Survey Scope: EBSA reviewed 37 plans by calling over 27,000 providers across 27 networks to verify provider directory information.

Provider Directory Accuracy: These surveys identified “material inaccuracies” in provider directory information—errors that could affect access to care.(2)

  • 36% of provider directory information was incorrect.
  • Errors included phone numbers, business addresses, provider specialties, and network participation.

Pathway to service: EBSA also tested whether participants could successfully rely on provider directory information to access care. To measure this, EBSA developed a “pathway to service” metric, which evaluated whether providers met specific criteria.(3)

  • 66% of medical and surgical providers did not meet all the criteria under EBSA’s “pathway to service” metric.
  • 74% of mental health and substance use disorder providers did not meet all the criteria under EBSA’s “pathway to service” metric.

Bottom line: Inaccuracies and access barriers to care can make it harder for participants and beneficiaries to find and use in-network providers.

What are the consequences of inaccurate directory information?

If a participant or beneficiary visited a provider who they were informed was in-network by the plan and is charged more than in-network cost sharing, the participant or beneficiary may be entitled to a refund.

Participants and beneficiaries who have questions about inaccurate directory information may contact EBSA or call (866) 444-3272. Participants and beneficiaries may also contact the No Surprises Help Desk or call (800) 985-3059.

Footnotes

  1. 42 U.S.C. 300gg-139. ↩
  2. EBSA assessed provider directory accuracy by identifying “material inaccuracies.” These are errors in provider directory information that could impact access to care, such as incorrect phone numbers, businesses addresses, provider specialties, or network participation. ↩
  3. To meet the “pathway to service” metric, a provider had to meet all of the following criteria:
    • A live person answered the phone or returned a voicemail;
    • The provider offered the listed specialty services;
    • The provider participated in the plan or issuer’s network;
    • The provider was accepting new patients; and
    • The wait time for the provider was 30 days or less. ↩