skip navigational linksDOL Seal - Link to DOL Home Page
Photos representing the workforce - Digital ImageryŠ copyright 2001 PhotoDisc, Inc.
dol.gov
July 25, 2008    DOL Home > News Release Archives > OSHA 1998   

Printer-Friendly Version

Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Occupational Safety and Health Administration

OSHA Press Release: OSHA Proposes $463,000 in Fines Against Claremont, N.H., Steel Firm Following Investigation of Two Worker Deaths [05/28/1998]

For more information call: (202) 219-8151

 
	 

The deaths of two workers resulted today in proposed penalties of $463,024 against Claremont Steel Corp., Claremont, N.H., for alleged violations of safety requirements, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) announced.

"This double tragedy might have been averted if Claremont had observed OSHA standards," said OSHA Administrator Charles N. Jeffress. "Strong penalties are warranted in cases such as this."

OSHA issued citations for 10 alleged willful violations with a total penalty of $416,500 and 38 alleged serious violations with a total penalty of $46,524. There were 32 alleged other-than-serious violations with no penalty.

Claremont is a bridge steel fabrication facility with about 55 employees. The company was previously known as East Coast Steel and, before that, as East Coast Steel Erectors, Inc.

On Dec. 16, 1997, two employees of the company were attempting to bend and shape two 62-foot long steel beams using a hydraulic jack placed between the centers of the beams. The employees were in the process of heating strategic points on the beams when the jack apparently slipped out and the two beams came crashing together, killing the workers instantly.

OSHA said that examination of the jack indicated it had been previously damaged during use so that it did not properly engage the load.

Earlier, there was another incident where an employee was seriously injured by a jack slipping. After the fatalities, OSHA inspectors notified Claremont that any damaged jacks still in service must be removed from service immediately. On Dec. 29, almost two weeks after the accident, an OSHA inspector found another damaged hydraulic jack in use, of the same make and model as the one involved in the deaths.

The alleged willful violations that relate directly to the fatal accident have to do with the employer's failure to properly inspect hydraulic jacks; allowing employees to use damaged hydraulic jacks; failure to equip hydraulic jacks with end caps; and failure to ensure that steel beam loads were properly cribbed, blocked or otherwise secured against displacement.

Claremont has 15 working days to contest the citations and proposed penalties before the independent Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission.

# # #

(Editor's Note: See Attached Fact Sheet for Summary of Citations and Proposed Penalties)


SUMMARY OF CITATIONS AND PROPOSED PENALTIES
CLAREMONT STEEL CORP.
CLAREMONT, N.H.


Alleged Willful Violations

  • Hydraulic jacks not equipped with caps and loads not cribbed, blocked or otherwise secured against displacement. (Grouped) $49,000
  • Hydraulic jacks not inspected as required and damaged hydraulic jacks not tagged or repaired prior to use. (Grouped) $49,000
  • Complete periodic inspections of overhead cranes had not been performed, and unsafe conditions were not corrected before placing cranes back in service after inspections (Grouped) $49,000
  • Semi-gantry crane rails not adequately spliced and did not have smooth joints and were not properly secured to foundations. (Grouped) $38,500
  • Custom-made rigging devices not marked with rated capacities nor proof tested. $38,500
  • Debris, including flammable/combustible residues from spraying operations, were allowed to accumulate; automatic sprinkler system not properly maintained and tested; and welding and cutting was in progress while sprinkler system was not fully operation. (Grouped) $38,500
  • Landing platforms or cages/wells not provided on fixed ladders of more than 20 feet. $38,500
  • Personal protective equipment not used when necessary for fall protection. $38,500
  • Overhead cab-operated cranes were not equipped with warning signal. $38,500
  • Crane load capacity was exceeded when moving plate. $38,500

Total penalties for alleged willful violations $416,500

(Willful violations are those committed with an intentional disregard of, or plain indifference to, the requirements of the Occupational Safety and Health Act and regulations. The penalties for this employer were reduced 30 percent because of the small size of the firm.)

Alleged Serious Violations

  • Citations for 38 violations of various standards dealing with crane safety; walking/working surfaces; ladders; exits; storage of flammable/combustible fluids; personal protective equipment; slings; lockout/tagout; forklifts; machine guarding; bulk oxygen storage; and electrical hazards. Penalties ranged from $637 to $3,500 per citation.

Total Penalties for Alleged Serious Violations $46,524

(A serious violation is defined as one in which there is a substantial probability that death or serious physical harm could result, and the employer knew or should have known of the hazard. The penalties for the citations involving serious violations for this employer were reduced 50 percent because of the firm's size and past history.)

GRAND TOTAL OF PROPOSED PENALTIES $463,024


Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.




Phone Numbers